Skip to main content

Vishwaroopam- Kamal Threatens to Leave India

Why so serious?

2013- The year so far. We started the first two/three with the death of the Delhi rape victim. This news was eclipsed by the trading of bullets across the border with Pakistan, some cricket matches with England- was it? And now, Vishwaroopam and the potential migration of Kamal Hassan with an impending increase in the price of staples.

Tina
This is what my month of news looks like, so excuse me if there was some other big thing that you thought I should have in there. I have exposed myself indeed, I don't get the newspaper at home or at work. Left to the mercy of the new Windows 8 news platform and my mum, to catch on the latest news.

Kamal wants to leave. I'm not a fan of Kamals' so I'm not sure that it's a great loss for us as a nation if we have him move. We'd still get the movies here, and it's not like I join him for coffee in the morning after my jog. So what's the big deal?



Has it happened before? 

The news article on MSN has compared the threat to MS Hussain's departure and consequent death in England. I think there are more recent examples of this migration/changing of passports business.

Bridget

  • Gerard Depardieu embraced Russian citizenship in December, as he was unhappy with the tax system in France
  • Bridget Bardot pioneered the idea in November, but has restated a few weeks ago that she will also turn Russian over the scheduled euthanization of two elephants held at the French Zoo
  • Gerard: courtesty guardian.uk
  • Tina Turner has joined the bandwagon, for no real real reason, except perhaps to just move to the Switzerland


And so will Mr Hassan, threaten to leave the country, to find himself a country that is more secular. Good Luck to him, I'm not sure a        nation state of that sort exists.

Why? 

09/11/2001: Changed everything, on the calendar. Over night, people who believed in the Islamic fate were subjected to silent 'racism' that with the passing years, like a drum roll, increase in pace and volume.

The crazy terrorist groups caught wind, and planned like the characters of Pinky and The Brain, for world domination. Together paranoia and extreme attention seeking methods have created the conditions today that  allow Mr Hassan to pass threats (I'll bet my blog, he's not moving out the country- he's just pouting!)

That's why the movie Vishwaroopam has the tagline: "Not all muslims are terrorists". Thirteen years ago, did someone have to put that up on a movie, like a statutory "Cigarettes are bad for your health"? 

The Argument

And have people stopped smoking? No
Are they all aware? Yes

That is why this is silly. People should be allowed to make movies the way they want to . We need to respect artistic freedom, because we all went to watch Schindler's List, Bombay, Kannathil Mithamittal, Inglorious Basterds or Passion of Christ and whole heap of other movies. 

> We didn't invent a time machine after (Schindler's List/ Inglorious Basterds), to go back in time and assassinate Hitler after we watched the movie.


> Neither did we book tickets to Sri Lanka and depending on which side we were on, join the LTTE or the government (KM). 

> Neither did we go out and kill all the Jews after that passionate (albeit dramatic) depiction of Jesus's betrayal and crucification on Passion of Christ. 

The same way half the population didn't stop being Christian after reading the Da Vinci Code or watching the movie. Nor did the Muslims who read Rushdie's Satanic Verses decide to be something else.

I don't understand why the people of the Muslim faith, who are objecting to the depiction of the religion and its practioners, make such a hue and cry to distinguish themselves from the terrorists, only to get offended if a Muslim terrorist is shown in a movie.

The only people who'd run out of the cinema hall, to go and attack the crowd are the ones who've been promised monetary compensation. It's the same ones who'd have robbed you, if they didn't get this assignment anyways. 

Conclusion

Censoring/ Blocking any movie is only going to make it more popular. And if it's a Kamal Hassan movie, you're screwed. And now the movie's become this 'religious' battle, with various lucky parties (judge included) getting free screenings. 

Kindda makes you think if the only way you'd be able to watch the movie in peace, is to find some thing else wrong with it, and then have Kamal Hassan invite you for a free screening

And it also kindda makes you think, what else is going to be sensitized, and how many more people are going to run around tarnishing the image of a beautiful religion, in the name of belonging to it. 

Comments

Anonymous said…
Nice analysis. I guess you are first at indiblogger to write on this issue.
R-A-J said…
I'm told that the Viswaroopam isuue is a larger political play at work.. there are bigger players working in the shadows... n I mean, 'real' Big

Think bout it - why would a court be so adamant that the movie will not get released, even when the Center has sided the actor, the censor board has cleared it and hello, even the movie has no references to whatever it is accused of?

The movie was to have a sequel.. now that Kamal is losing bout 30 - 80 Cr, people can buy this movie off him for cheap.. look at who will gain from this and you could figure out the players in this murky game.

Poor Kamal really.. the guy ended up as the loser.
Akshay Kumar G said…
We are slowly becoming an over-sensitive and intolerant nation. There is a controversy about every single thing these days. I don't blame Kamal Hassan for thinking the way he has. There is definitely a political game going on at the behest of Kamal and he has only been made the guinea pig in this whole drama. Sad to see one of the finest actors of this country, a legend is being treated in this way.
Saro said…
@Flamesofthoughts: just read it last night, and had to draw the parallels!

RAJ: Interestingly enough, I heard the same thing today at work when we were talking about this. That it was political..and you have an excellent point. This one's one that I will wait and watch.. And i resonate your thought, poor him. It's unfair really.

AG: Totally agree on the fact that we are becoming over sensitive! And it's such a pity he's being kicked around like a ball. We can all empathize because at one point or another, we've all been a victim to this, and all I can say, is there's a trend and it's a statement if he has to leave this democracy, to have freedom of speech, thought and action.
Jack said…
Saro,

I agree with you that we should not interfere in artistic issues including movies but at the same time who indulges in this should also ensure that feelings of others are not hurt unless it is a factual depiction of events. You have analyzed the issue well. He is gaining a lot of publicity.

Take care
x said…
11/11/2001?
And great to know there are people in my generation who know Gerard Depardieu.
Saro said…
Nice catch, corrected :) yeah I do, not to well though
Saro said…
Nice catch, corrected :) yeah I do, not to well though
Saro said…
@Jack: just got back from watching the movie, trust me, there's nothing in there that is offensive.
Anonymous said…
Hitler's face...

Photoshop Level: Kapil Sibal.

Popular posts from this blog

Celebrations

This post has been published by me as a part of the Blog-a-Ton 16 ; the sixteenth edition of the online marathon of Bloggers; where we decide and we write. To be part of the next edition, visit and start following Blog-a-Ton . It was a hard ground that felt like sand paper. When he started his journey, it was the soles of his feet that were in contact with the ground, but now as he pulled himself closer to the station, it was his whole body. His elbows were scraped, bloody and fresh scab peeled bled out to leave a trail of red on the wicked hot dusty ground of pain and suffering. All around him slow moving bodies crawled towards the direction of hope, all along leaving patterns of blood, sweat, skin and pus. These bodies had seen civil wars, droughts, genocide and lived to tell a tale of a people who now belonged to a nation listed as one of the poorest countries in the world. This is now, but before the list, was a struggle of massive proportions, under reported and quietly hidden

Escape

This post has been published by me as a part of the Blog-a-Ton 10 ; the tenth edition of the online marathon of Bloggers; where we decide and we write. To be part of the next edition, visit and start following Blog-a-Ton . The Temple Widow A narrow dirt path, generously peppered with tiny pebbles, tiny miniatures of their gargantuan ancestors, leads to a bridge. It hangs, rickety and old. Old but not well used, old like abandoned and not frequently used. The bridge hangs low over a small stream that slowly gurgles past, happy unlike those that visit the place. The bridge leads to a temple. It is not very big, only perhaps the size of a small hut and at the most the size of an average temple hall. The temple has no deity; the temple has no one corner that doesn’t look like the other. It is clean, well swept, and empty. It has no furniture, and excepting a series of well spaced out windows, the walls remains uninterrupted. She stumbles in, the lady. She is not very tal

Time Travel

This post has been published by me as a part of the Blog-a-Ton 8 ; the eighth edition of the online marathon of Bloggers; where we decide and we write. To be part of the next edition, visit and start following Blog-a-Ton . I haven't got the memory of a vedic tantric. Neither do I ever claim to remember all. All I know is what I know, question my memory if you want to. I don't ask you to remember, I don't ask you to believe. In fact, I'm not asking you for anything at all. It is your choice to be here, to read this. So no, I don't owe you a favor. I happened to chance upon a watch, on one of my travels. Turning the dials of such a watch, could transport you to the past, to the future, to any time. But time, my friend, is not how you think it is. It is not a straight line, and you cannot just by chance hop into the world of dinosaurs and wooden weapons. It is a series of transparencies, like films of clean sheets of paper laid on top of each other. You look from above